Why Do Global Platforms Confuse OIDAR with Marketplace GST Rules?
Introduction
Many global platforms assume all digital transactions follow the same tax model. This is where confusion begins. India has a clear separation between OIDAR and marketplace GST rules, but global platforms often mix them up. In this blog, we explain why this confusion happens and how these two categories differ in simple terms. This mix-up leads to wrong registrations, wrong filings, and compliance risks.
What Makes OIDAR Different from Marketplace GST Rules?
India separates digital services from marketplace transactions through clear definitions in the IGST Act. OIDAR covers online information and database access or retrieval services. It includes SaaS, AI tools, digital downloads, cloud software, and online streaming. These services operate fully online and fall under Section 2(17). Marketplace GST rules apply only when a platform facilitates sales of goods or services for others. This includes e-commerce operators like Amazon or app stores with third party sellers. When global platforms see both categories happening online, they assume the tax rules are the same. This creates the first layer of confusion.
Why the Digital Context Misleads Global Platforms?
The digital environment looks similar from the outside. A user pays online. A tool or product is delivered online. A platform hosts the transaction. But in GST law, the difference is sharp. OIDAR is about delivering your own digital service. A marketplace is about enabling someone else’s supply. Global platforms often apply the broader e-commerce interpretation they use in regions like the EU or US. India uses a specific OIDAR framework with its own compliance model, and this difference is not always understood by foreign tax teams.
How Tax Liability Creates More Confusion?
Under OIDAR, the tax depends on the location of the user. If an Indian consumer uses a digital service, the foreign provider must register in India and pay 18 percent IGST. If the user is a GST registered business, the business pays GST under reverse charge. Under marketplace rules, the platform may become the deemed supplier. This makes the platform liable for GST on certain categories. Foreign companies often assume marketplace liability applies to both digital content and SaaS. India treats OIDAR separately, and this gap is where many global platforms make errors.
Terminology Overlap and Lack of Familiarity
Teams working for global platforms are familiar with VAT or marketplace rules in their home countries. Many of them use the phrase “marketplace tax” to describe any digital transaction. This leads to misinterpretation in India. A SaaS product is not a marketplace supply. A digital subscription is not a marketplace supply. A streaming service is not a marketplace supply. But the shared digital space makes them appear related. When tax advisors outside India are not updated on OIDAR changes, the classification becomes even more confusing.
OIDAR vs Marketplace GST
|
Topic |
OIDAR (Digital Service You Provide) |
Marketplace GST (Platform Where Others Sell) |
|
What it means |
You provide your own online service directly to users. |
You allow other sellers to list and sell on your platform. |
|
Examples |
SaaS, AI tools, streaming apps, cloud software. |
Amazon, app stores, food delivery apps, service aggregators. |
|
Who is the supplier |
The digital platform itself. |
The third party seller, but the platform may be treated as the supplier for GST. |
|
Who pays GST in B2C |
The foreign provider must register and pay 18 percent IGST if the user is in India. |
The marketplace may have to collect and pay GST for the sellers. |
|
Who pays GST in B2B |
The Indian business pays GST under reverse charge. |
In many cases, the marketplace handles GST for the seller. |
|
How GST is decided |
Based on the user’s location. If the user is in India, GST applies. |
Also based on user location, but tax often flows through the marketplace. |
|
Why confusion happens |
Global platforms think all online activity is “e-commerce.” |
They assume every online service works like a marketplace. |
|
Main risk |
Wrong category leads to wrong registration and filings. |
Marketplace may miss GST they were responsible to pay. |
Why This Distinction Matters for Global Platforms?
When a global platform misclassified its services, it may take the wrong GST registration, file the wrong returns, or skip returns entirely. This can cause notices, tax demands, and long-term compliance risks. Correct classification protects both the platform and its users. It also ensures accurate tax flow into India, which is the purpose of both OIDAR and marketplace GST rules.
How Ebizfiling Works for you?
-
We at Ebizfiling identify whether your service qualifies as OIDAR or marketplace activity.
-
We guide you with the correct GST registration type.
-
We manage GSTR 5A or standard GST filings based on your category.
-
We create a compliance plan for cross border digital supplies.
-
We support you with ongoing advisory for GST rules in India.
In short ,
Global platforms often confuse OIDAR with marketplace GST rules because the digital environment looks similar at the surface. But the tax logic behind both is separate. Understanding this difference helps global platforms stay compliant and manage gst rules correctly while operating in India.
Suggested Read :
How Online Health Platforms can trigger OIDAR in India?
OIDAR Compliance Roadmap for Foreign Startups
Why Foreign CRM Platforms Reassess OIDAR Liability GST 2023-24?
Why User Location Matters for OIDAR India?
Do Digital Nomads Abroad Trigger OIDAR for India?
Frequently Asked Questions on OIDAR vs Marketplace GST Rules
1. Why do global platforms confuse OIDAR with marketplace rules?
Many global platforms operate only in digital environments, so they assume all online activities fall under one common tax rule. In India, digital services and marketplace transactions fall under different parts of the GST law, which is why mixing them up often leads to mistakes.
2. Is every online service classified as OIDAR?
No. A service counts as OIDAR only when it is delivered entirely online by the provider. Marketplace activity involves independent sellers using a platform to sell goods or services, so it is treated differently under GST.
3. How does GST apply to a foreign SaaS provider?
When a foreign SaaS provider sells to an Indian consumer, the provider must register for GST and pay IGST in India. If the buyer is an Indian business with GST registration, the business must pay tax under reverse charge instead of the provider.
4. Does an app store fall under marketplace GST rules?
Yes, when an app store allows third party developers to sell apps or digital products, it acts as a marketplace and must follow marketplace GST rules. However, the store’s own digital or subscription based services may still be treated as OIDAR.
5. Is streaming an OIDAR service?
Yes. Streaming platforms deliver digital content directly to users without involving any third party seller. This makes streaming a classic example of an OIDAR service under Indian GST rules.
6. Can marketplace rules apply to SaaS?
No. SaaS providers deliver their own digital service directly to users. Since there is no third party seller involved, SaaS does not fall under marketplace rules and is treated as OIDAR.
7. Why is the place of supply important in OIDAR?
Place of supply helps identify where the user is located. If the user is in India, GST applies to the service even if the provider is outside India. This keeps tax aligned to the location where the service is actually consumed.
8. Do global platforms need separate GST registration for OIDAR?
Yes. Any foreign platform that offers digital services to Indian consumers must register for GST in India, even if it has no office, employees, or physical presence in the country.
9. What happens if a platform misclassifies its service?
A wrong classification may lead to incorrect GST filings, missed tax payments, or the wrong party paying the tax. Over time, this can result in notices, penalties, or compliance disputes with GST authorities.
10. How does OIDAR protect Indian tax revenue?
OIDAR rules ensure that foreign digital platforms pay GST whenever Indian users consume their services. This prevents revenue loss for India and keeps the tax system fair for both local and global service providers.
OIDAR Registration
Get OIDAR Registration done by Ebizfiling Professionals within minutes!
About Ebizfiling -
December 16, 2025 By Steffy A
Why Foreign Influencer Platforms Need OIDAR Registration? Let’s Begin Let’s begin. Foreign influencers today reach Indian audiences through apps, portals, and digital platforms, earning revenue via subscriptions, commissions, and brand campaigns. When digital services are provided to users located in […]
December 16, 2025 By Steffy A
Subscription Traps: Auto-Renew OIDAR Tax Risks Introduction Subscription traps are becoming common across digital platforms that rely on auto-renew models. Many global companies overlook how these subscriptions trigger OIDAR tax liability in India. This gap often leads to serious tax […]
December 16, 2025 By Steffy A
OIDAR for Creators: GST Risks for Foreign E-Coaches Introduction Creators today reach global audiences through digital platforms, courses, and coaching programs. Many foreign e-coaches serve Indian users without understanding India’s OIDAR framework. This creates serious GST risks for creators operating […]