Branch Office vs Indian Subsidiary: Strategic Differences

Branch Office: Overview

Setting up a Branch Office is a common option for foreign companies looking to enter the Indian market without creating a new legal entity. It works as an extension of the parent company abroad, meaning all the business done by the branch in India is on behalf of the overseas head office.

This model is ideal for companies that want to:

• Test the Indian market before committing long-term
• Promote their existing products or services
• Offer support or consultancy
• Conduct research related to their business

A Branch Office helps build presence without taking on the full compliance requirements that come with forming a new Indian company.

What Can a Branch Office Do in India?

According to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), Branch Offices can carry out only a limited set of activities. These are allowed under the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA). Here’s what your branch can legally do:

• Import and Export: Handle trading operations like buying from or selling to India.
• Professional Services: Provide consultancy or technical expertise in fields such as engineering, IT, marketing, and finance.
• Research Work: Carry out research tied to your main business operations.
• Promote Collaborations: Help build partnerships between Indian and foreign companies in technical or financial areas.
• Representation: Work as a local buying or selling agent for the parent company.
• IT and Software Services: Offer software development or IT services from India.
• Technical Support: Deliver after-sales support for products of the parent company.
• Act for Airlines or Shipping Firms: Represent international shipping or airline companies in India.

Note: Branch Offices are not allowed to manufacture products or do retail trading in India unless they are operating in a Special Economic Zone (SEZ), where certain permissions may apply.

Regulatory Framework

Branch Offices are tightly regulated. The following laws and RBI guidelines govern how they are formed and operated:

• FEMA, 1999: The main law for foreign exchange transactions in India.
• FEMA Notification No. 22/2000-RB: Specific to Branch, Liaison, and Project Offices of foreign companies.
• RBI Master Direction No. 10/2015-16: Outlines the current rules and application process.

A foreign company must get approval from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) before opening a branch. It must also register with the Registrar of Companies (RoC) and follow reporting and compliance procedures regularly.

More info: MCA Official Portal

Taxation of Branch Offices

A Branch Office must pay income tax in India on any income earned from local operations. Unlike an Indian company, it is not treated as a separate legal person, so profits are considered part of the foreign parent’s income.

• Tax Rate: Typically, income is taxed at the rate of 40% (plus surcharge and cess) for foreign companies.
• No Local Tax Benefits: Branch Offices can’t claim deductions or exemptions reserved for Indian startups or MSMEs.
• Repatriation of Profits: After paying taxes and completing the necessary formalities, profits can be sent back to the parent company abroad.

Key Takeaways

• A Branch Office is not a separate company but an arm of the foreign parent.
• It can only do specific, RBI-approved activities.
• Requires RBI and RoC approval and must follow Indian compliance laws.
• Cannot do retail or manufacturing (unless in SEZs).
• Subject to Indian tax, without startup exemptions.
• Profits can be sent back overseas after paying Indian taxes.

Indian Subsidiary: Overview

An Indian Subsidiary is a company set up in India under Indian laws, and it operates independently from its foreign parent company. It can be formed as either:

• Private Limited Company: Best suited for small to medium-sized businesses.
• Public Limited Company: Designed for larger companies with more extensive operations.

Regulatory Framework

Indian Subsidiaries follow these key rules:

• Companies Act, 2013: The main law that governs companies in India.
• Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA), 1999: Controls foreign investments and related transactions.

Taxation

Indian Subsidiaries enjoy several tax benefits, such as:

• Corporate Tax Rates: Typically 25% for companies with turnover up to ₹400 crore, and 30% for those above that.
• Goods and Services Tax (GST): Charged if turnover exceeds ₹40 lakh (₹20 lakh for service providers). Subsidiaries can also claim credits on GST paid for business expenses.
• Capital Gains Exemptions: Tax exemptions on long-term gains from shares held for more than two years.
• R&D Deductions: Companies can deduct 150% of qualifying research and development expenses under Section 35(2AB) of the Income Tax Act.

Compliance Requirements

Indian Subsidiaries need to:

• File annual returns and financial reports with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA).
• Submit income tax returns each year according to the Income Tax Act.
• Regularly file GST returns, if registered under GST.

Key Differences Between Branch Office and Indian Subsidiary

Advantages and Disadvantages

Branch Office

Advantages:

• Direct Control: A Branch Office acts as an extension of the foreign parent company, so the parent has direct control over its operations in India. This makes it easier to manage the business and keep everything aligned with your global strategy.
• Simplified Setup: Setting up a Branch Office is usually quicker and involves less paperwork compared to registering a new company. This makes it a good choice if you want to enter the Indian market fast.

Disadvantages:

• Limited Activities: Branch Offices are restricted to certain activities approved by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), like export/import, consultancy, or market research. They cannot carry out regular business activities like manufacturing or selling products in India.
• Taxation: Although Branch Offices must pay taxes on income earned in India, they don’t get access to many tax benefits or exemptions available to Indian companies. This could lead to higher tax costs compared to a subsidiary.

Indian Subsidiary

Advantages:

• Operational Flexibility: An Indian Subsidiary is a separate company under Indian law, which means it can engage in almost any business activity. This gives your business more freedom to expand and adapt to the local market.
• Tax Benefits: Subsidiaries can take advantage of various tax incentives, including exemptions and deductions, which can help save money and improve financial planning.

Disadvantages:

• Complex Setup: Registering a subsidiary takes more time and involves detailed procedures. You will have to complete company registration, submit multiple documents, and meet several legal requirements.
• Regulatory Compliance: Subsidiaries must follow the Companies Act, 2013, and other Indian laws.This means you’ll need to handle routine tasks like filing annual reports with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA), getting your accounts audited, and following good governance practices.

Decision-Making Considerations

When deciding between a Branch Office and an Indian Subsidiary, here are some important points to think about:

• Type of Business Activities: If your business mainly involves trading, consulting, or providing professional services, a Branch Office might be enough. But if you want to carry out a wider range of activities, setting up a Subsidiary is usually a better choice.
• Tax Impact: Check the tax rules and benefits for both options to understand which one will work best for your financial plans.
• Compliance Needs: Each structure comes with its own legal requirements and reporting obligations in India. Make sure you know what’s involved before choosing.
• Future Investment Plans: Consider how much you want to invest and if you might need to raise capital or bring in investors later. This can help you decide which structure fits your goals better.

Conclusion

Choosing between a branch office and an Indian subsidiary comes down to your business goals and how you want to operate in India. A branch office is easier to set up and gives you direct control, which works well for limited activities. But if you want more flexibility to grow and benefit from tax advantages, setting up an Indian subsidiary is usually the smarter option for building a solid presence in the market.

Suggested Read :

What is CIN Number of Company?

Branch Office and Indian Subsidiary

Holding and Subsidiary Company in India

How to start a Subsidiary Company in India?

Foreign Subsidiary Company Compliance in India

FAQs