W8BEN vs TRC: Reporting Foreign Income for Indian Freelancers

What is W8BEN?

W8BEN is a form from the US tax authorities (IRS) that foreign freelancers, including those in India, use to prove they are not US residents. This form helps you show your foreign status and lets you claim benefits under the tax agreement between India and the US.

Why is W8BEN Important for Indian Freelancers?

If you’re an Indian freelancer working with clients in the US, submitting the W8BEN form helps reduce the amount of tax your US clients have to withhold from your payments. Normally, without this form, they might withhold up to 30% tax. But with W8BEN, that rate can drop to zero or a lower percentage, meaning you get to keep more of your earnings. Just remember, this form is given to your US clients—not the Indian tax department—and it doesn’t replace your responsibility to report income in India.

What is a Tax Residency Certificate (TRC)?

A Tax Residency Certificate, or TRC, is an official document from the Indian Income Tax Department. It proves that you are a tax resident of India for a specific financial year. This certificate helps to show where you pay taxes, which is important if you earn money from outside India.

How Does a TRC Help Indian Freelancers?

If you earn income from foreign clients and they deduct tax before paying you, the TRC can help you avoid paying tax twice on that same income. You can use this certificate to claim credit for the tax already paid abroad when filing your Indian tax returns. This way, you only pay the correct amount of tax overall, and don’t end up overpaying.

Why Should Indian Freelancers Understand W8BEN vs TRC?

How to Use W8BEN and TRC for Reporting Foreign Income

Step-by-step Process for W8BEN Submission

• Download the form: Start by downloading the W8BEN form from the official IRS website. This form is used to tell your US clients that you are a foreign individual eligible for reduced tax withholding.
• Fill in your details: Carefully fill out the form with your personal information. Make sure to include your Indian Tax Identification Number, commonly known as PAN. This helps link your foreign income with your Indian tax records.
• Submit to your US client: Once completed, send the form directly to your US client or the payer. They use this form to apply the right tax treaty benefits when making payments to you.
• Renew regularly: Remember that the W8BEN is valid for three years. You should renew or update the form if any of your details change to keep enjoying the tax benefits without interruption.

Step-by-step Process to Obtain TRC

• File your Income Tax Return: Before applying for a Tax Residency Certificate, make sure you have filed your Indian Income Tax Return for the relevant financial year. This shows your compliance with Indian tax laws.
• Apply online for TRC: Go to the Indian Income Tax Department’s e-filing portal at incometax.gov.in and apply for the TRC. The online process is straightforward and convenient.
• Upload required documents: You’ll need to upload certain documents like your PAN card and proof of residency in India. These documents help prove that you are a tax resident in India for the financial year.
• Receive your TRC electronically: After verification, the Income Tax Department will issue your TRC electronically. You can then use this certificate to claim tax benefits and avoid double taxation on your foreign income.

What are the Benefits of Using W8BEN and TRC?

Benefits of Using W8BEN

• Reduces US Tax Withholding on Payments: When you work with clients in the US, they’re required to hold back a part of your payment as tax. Without the W8BEN form, this tax withholding can be as high as 30%. By submitting the W8BEN, you let your US clients know you’re an Indian resident and eligible for special tax benefits. This usually lowers the tax they hold back, sometimes even to zero.
• Increases Your Take-Home Pay from US Clients: Since the W8BEN reduces how much tax is deducted upfront, you get more money in your hand right away. This means better cash flow and higher earnings without waiting for any tax refunds later.
• Prevents Extra Tax Deductions: Without the W8BEN, US clients may deduct the highest tax rate by default. Using the form ensures they apply the correct, lower tax rate right away, saving you from unnecessary tax deductions and the hassle of claiming refunds.

Benefits of Using Tax Residency Certificate (TRC)

• Helps You Claim Foreign Tax Credits in India: If you’ve paid tax in another country on your earnings, the TRC helps you get credit for that tax when you file your Indian tax return. This means you won’t pay tax twice on the same income.
• Stops Double Taxation on Your Income: India has agreements with many countries to avoid taxing the same income twice. The TRC proves that you’re an Indian tax resident, so you can use these agreements to avoid paying tax twice — once abroad and again in India.
• Keeps You Compliant with Indian Tax Rules: Having a TRC shows you’re following Indian tax laws properly. It helps you report your foreign income correctly and claim the benefits you’re entitled to, reducing the risk of fines or legal trouble later.

Challenges Indian Freelancers Face with Foreign Income Reporting

• Confusion between forms and their purposes: Many freelancers aren’t sure when to use W8BEN or TRC, which can lead to mistakes.
• Difficulty in applying for TRC due to paperwork: Getting a TRC involves several documents, and the process can feel overwhelming.
• Managing different tax laws in India and abroad: Understanding and following tax rules from two countries can be tricky and time-consuming.
• Ensuring timely submission of W8BEN to foreign clients: Missing deadlines for submitting W8BEN can cause higher tax deductions.
• Properly declaring foreign income in Indian tax returns: Reporting overseas earnings correctly on Indian returns can be confusing and needs careful attention.

What Happens if Freelancers Don’t Use W8BEN or TRC Correctly?

• Higher tax withholding by foreign clients: Without W8BEN, your US clients may withhold more tax than needed, reducing your payment.
• Double taxation without relief claims: Not using TRC can mean paying tax twice—once abroad and again in India.
• Possible penalties or interest: Incorrect or late tax filings can lead to fines or extra charges from tax authorities.
• Difficulty in tax refund claims or audits: Mistakes in using these forms can cause problems when claiming refunds or during tax checks by Indian officials.

Conclusion

Indian freelancers earning money from abroad need to know the difference between W8BEN and TRC to make the most of tax benefits and stay on the right side of the law. The W8BEN form helps lower the tax your foreign clients, especially in the US, withhold from your payments. On the other hand, the TRC proves you’re a tax resident of India and lets you claim credit for taxes paid overseas. Using both forms correctly can save you money, reduce confusion, and keep your tax matters in order.

If you need help with W8BEN or TRC, it’s a good idea to talk to a tax expert or visit the official Income Tax Department website for guidance.

Suggested Read :

How Indian Avoid Double Taxation on US Income?

Form 15CA

Filing of Form 10F by Non Residents

Best Tax Saving US Business Structure

Tax filing requirement in the USA

FAQs